Did you know there’s a forbidden penny that collectors say could be worth over $100,000? 🪙 That’s right—the 1959-D Wheat Penny is one of the most mysterious coins in U.S. history, officially denied by the U.S. Mint but still rumored to exist.
If you’re lucky enough to find one, here’s how to check if it’s real, get it verified, and sell it for maximum profit. 🚀
🔍 Part 1: How to Spot a Genuine 1959-D Wheat Penny
✅ Step 1: Check the Date (Most Important!)
- The coin must clearly show 1959 (not altered from 1958).
- Use a 10x magnifier to make sure there are no tool marks or changes to the numbers.
- The numbers should look sharp with original mint shine.
✅ Step 2: Look at the Reverse (Back Side)
- You should see two wheat stalks (like 1958 pennies).
- The words “ONE CENT” must match the exact 1958 style.
✅ Step 3: Inspect the Mint Mark
- Only a “D” mint mark (Denver) is possible.
- Any “S” mint mark is automatically fake ❌.
✅ Step 4: Weight & Composition
- Real copper wheat pennies weigh 3.11 grams.
- If it’s 2.5g (zinc), it’s fake.
- Test with a magnet—real copper won’t stick.
✅ Step 5: Edge Check
- Run your fingernail around the edge—should feel smooth, not rough.
⚠️ Red Flags of Fake Coins:
- Different patina on front vs back
- Mushy or weak lettering
- Signs of glue or solder
🏆 Part 2: How to Verify If It’s Real
1️⃣ Document Everything
- Take clear photos & videos in natural light.
- Weigh the coin with a precision scale.
2️⃣ Submit to Grading Services
- PCGS (best option, $150+ for error coins).
- NGC ($100+, uses VarietyPlus).
- ANACS (good for legal documentation).
3️⃣ Get Expert Opinions
- Trusted experts: Fred Weinberg, Mike Byers.
- Post photos (not location) in PCGS forums.
💵 Part 3: Where to Sell a $100K Penny
🏛 Auction Houses (Best Value)
- Heritage Auctions – famous for rare errors.
- Stack’s Bowers – strong global buyer base.
🤝 Private Sales (Faster)
- Trusted dealers: Legend Numismatics, David Lawrence RC.
- Elite collector networks or secure Facebook groups.
🏛 Museums (For Legacy)
- Smithsonian Institution
- ANA Money Museum
⚖️ Part 4: Legal & Tax Protection
📜 Write a provenance letter (notarized if possible).
🔒 Use insured shipping (Brinks, armored courier).
⚖️ Talk to a numismatic attorney if ownership is challenged.
💸 Taxes: Sales over $20,000 require IRS reporting (Form 1099-B).
🌟 Why This Coin Is Legendary
✔️ The only U.S. coin ever banned by the government.
✔️ If real, it rewrites American coin history.
✔️ A single coin could make you $100,000+ richer.
Leave a Reply