Imagine finding a 1959 penny with a wheat reverse. Sounds impossible, right? By 1959, the U.S. Mint had already switched to the Lincoln Memorial reverse. But one mysterious coin has surfaced — and it sold for nearly $50,000 at auction.
Could there be another one out there? Let’s dive into why this coin is so rare, how to spot a real one, and what to do if you think you’ve found it.
🪙 Why the 1959 Wheat Penny Shouldn’t Exist
- From 1909–1958, U.S. pennies had the classic wheat ears reverse 🌾.
- In 1959, to celebrate Lincoln’s 150th birthday, the Mint switched to the Lincoln Memorial reverse. 🏛️
- So in theory:
✅ All 1959 pennies should feature the Lincoln Memorial.
❌ None should have the wheat reverse.
But somehow… one slipped through.
💰 The $48,300 Auction Mystery
In 2019, a 1959-D Wheat Reverse Lincoln cent sold for $48,300 at auction.
Why it’s so valuable:
- 🧪 Authenticated by PCGS (Professional Coin Grading Service).
- 🔬 Struck at the Denver Mint (“D” mint mark).
- 🧬 Believed to be a mint error — possibly made intentionally by an employee.
To date, only one authenticated example exists, making it one of the most mysterious coins in U.S. history.
🔍 How to Spot a Real 1959 Wheat Penny
If you ever come across a 1959 penny with a wheat back, check for:
✅ Obverse (Front)
- Correct “1959” date, with or without the “D” mint mark.
- Sharp, even lettering (especially in LIBERTY and IN GOD WE TRUST).
- Lincoln’s bust should have smooth, consistent details.
✅ Reverse (Back)
- Classic wheat ears design 🌾.
- Clear “ONE CENT” and “UNITED STATES OF AMERICA” text.
- No signs of re-engraving, tooling, or tampering.
⚠️ Red Flags & Fakes
Unfortunately, most “1959 wheat pennies” seen online are counterfeits. Common tricks include:
❌ Fusing two coins (a 1959 obverse with a pre-1958 reverse).
❌ Re-engraving or stamping a fake wheat reverse.
❌ Casting cheap copies with poor detail and mismatched lettering.
👀 Example: In a recent viral TikTok, a 1959 wheat penny was shown — but closer inspection revealed misaligned letters and off-looking details. Experts confirmed: not real.
🛡️ Think Yours Might Be Genuine? Do This First
If you think you’ve found the real deal:
✔ Handle with gloves 🧤 (oils from your skin can harm it).
✔ Take high-quality photos in natural light. 📸
✔ Submit to PCGS or NGC for professional authentication.
✔ Avoid selling on eBay without certification — scammers are everywhere.
✔ Never clean the coin 🚫 — cleaning erases collector value.
🧠 Final Thoughts: A Collector’s Dream
Most “1959 wheat pennies” are fake, but the one real example proves it’s possible. Another authentic coin could still be sitting in someone’s collection or coin jar.
👉 Check carefully before dismissing a find.
👉 Compare with verified images of the real one.
👉 Get it authenticated — because if it’s genuine, you could be holding a $50,000 treasure. 💎
Leave a Reply