Awesome — you’ve got a 1922 No “D” penny and want a friendly, emoji-spiced, step-by-step plan to sell it for the most money. Below is a practical checklist and a stepwise playbook from first check → graded → sell & ship safely. Let’s turn that penny into profit (safely)! 🪙🚀
Quick reminder
Handle with care — don’t clean it. Cleaning destroys collector value. 🧤
Step-by-Step Selling Guide
1) First quick check 🔎
- Confirm it’s 1922 and looks like there’s no “D” under the date.
- Use a 10x–30x loupe or phone macro to inspect for traces of a rubbed-off mint mark vs. true missing mint mark.
- Take initial photos (phone OK) for your record. 📸
2) Document & photograph properly 📷✅
Photo checklist (must-have):
- Obverse (front) — straight on + slightly angled
- Reverse (back) — straight on + angled
- Close-ups of the date area (where the “D” should be)
- Full coin + a ruler or US quarter for scale
- Edge shot
Tip: Use natural light, no flash reflections. Use a plain dark or neutral background. 🖼️
3) Weigh & note condition ⚖️
- Record visible wear, scratches, nicks, rim damage.
- Note approximate grade if you know it (e.g., VG, AU, MS). Honesty matters for buyers.
- Keep these notes with your photos.
4) Get an expert opinion (optional but cheap) 🧠
- Post photos to trusted collector forums or a reputable coin dealer for a quick opinion. (Free or small fee.)
- This helps decide whether grading is worth it.
5) Decide whether to grade (PCGS / NGC) 🛡️
Why grade? Certified coins sell for significantly more and attract top buyers.
- Typical result: graded 1922 No D in decent condition can sell well above raw examples.
- If coin is decent condition (good details, not trashed) → grade it. If beat up, grading fees may not be worth it.
How: Submit through PCGS or NGC submission portals (follow their submission instructions). Expect grading + handling time. ⏳
6) Estimate value & choose a selling route 📈
Compare completed sales (similar grade/error) on:
- Auction houses (Heritage, GreatCollections) — best for high value 🏛️
- eBay — wide audience, good for mid-value but expect fees and buyer vetting 💻
- Private sale to a reputable dealer or collector — may be quicker but lower than auction 🤝
Tip: For high-value items, auctions + consignment usually get the best prices.
7) Prepare listing materials (title & description) ✍️
Sample title: “1922-D ‘No D’ Lincoln Wheat Cent — Major Mint Error — PCGS/NGC Eligible”
Description bullets to include:
- Year / alleged error (1922 No D)
- Condition summary (e.g., AU-50, circulated, etc.)
- Photos & grading status (if graded, slab details)
- Provenance if any (where/when you found it)
- Shipping, insurance, payment terms
Be transparent — tell the full story and include good photos. 📚
8) Set pricing strategy & reserve (if auction) 💸
- If consigning to auction: decide on reserve price (minimum you’ll accept).
- Consider a “no reserve” only if you want max exposure and accept risk.
- For private sales: set a firm price or accept offers. Use comparables (recent sales) to justify price.
9) Vet buyers & accept secure payments 🛡️
- Accept: wired bank transfers, certified/cashier’s checks (verify bank), PayPal (only if seller protections suffice).
- Avoid: personal checks (unless cleared), risky escrow services unless reputable.
- For very high values, use an escrow service or auction house middleman. 🔒
10) Pack & ship like a pro 📦✈️
- Use a hard case / slab (if graded) → bubble wrap → small box.
- Ship insured for full declared value, with tracking & signature required. Insure via carrier’s declared value or third-party insurer for high amounts.
- Consider registered mail / insured courier (FedEx/UPS with signature + adult ID). For 4- or 5-figure items, require signature and add “Do not leave” instructions. 📬
11) After sale: document everything 🧾
- Save photos of the packed coin, tracking, insurance policy, and buyer communication.
- Send tracking info and expected delivery to the buyer.
- Keep receipts for tax/reporting purposes.
12) Taxes & legal notes 📑
- Profits from sales may be taxable. Consult a tax advisor about capital gains and reporting.
- For extremely high sales, talk to a tax professional / attorney beforehand.
Quick checklist (copy this and use it)
- Don’t clean the coin 🧤
- Take quality photos 📸
- Weigh & note condition ⚖️
- Get quick expert opinion (optional) 🧠
- Grade with PCGS/NGC if in decent condition 🛡️
- Choose selling venue (auction / eBay / private) 🏛️💻🤝
- Create clear listing + price strategy ✍️
- Vet buyer + accept secure payment 🔐
- Ship insured + track + require signature 📦
- Save paperwork + consult tax pro 📑
Quick pro tips 💡
- Grading often multiplies value for high-quality error coins — factor fees + shipping into your math. 💰
- Auction houses take consignor fees but deliver top buyers and marketing.
- Be patient. Rare coin markets can move slowly but pay well for perfection. ⏳
- Always ask for references when dealing with private buyers.
Leave a Reply