How a Wartime Minting Mistake Turned a Common Penny into a $1.7 Million Treasure
Imagine discovering a penny so rare it could buy a luxury home. That’s the story of the 1943 bronze Lincoln cent, a legendary coin born out of World War II chaos. Today, it holds the record as the most valuable U.S. cent ever sold. Here’s what makes it special, how to identify a genuine example, and what to do if you think you’ve found one.
⚔️ Wartime Origins: Why This Error Happened
- 1943 Mint Policy: Save the Copper!
During WWII, copper was desperately needed for ammunition and wiring. To conserve supplies, the U.S. Mint struck pennies from zinc-coated steel instead of bronze. - The Mistake: Bronze Planchets Left Behind
Despite the switch, a few leftover bronze blanks from 1942 were accidentally used in 1943.
👉 Experts estimate only 10–15 genuine bronze cents exist.
👉 PCGS and NGC have certified just six known examples.
🧠 Rarity Compared: 1943 Bronze vs. 1944 Steel
| Feature | 1943 Bronze | 1944 Steel |
|---|---|---|
| Estimated Survivors | 10–15 | ~30 |
| Collector Awareness | Low in 1943 | Higher in 1944 |
| Public Holdings | 3 in museums | Mostly private collections |
🔍 How to Identify a Real 1943 Bronze Penny
Diagnostic Checklist:
| Feature | 1943 Bronze Cent | 1943 Steel Cent |
|---|---|---|
| Weight | 3.11g (±0.05g) | 2.70g |
| Magnetism | Non-magnetic | Strongly magnetic |
| Color | Reddish-brown | Silvery-gray |
| Sound | Dull “clink” | High-pitched “ping” |
| Edge | Solid bronze | Zinc-coated steel |
Known Mintmarks:
- Philadelphia: (no mintmark)
- Denver: “D”
- San Francisco: “S”
💰 Grading & Value: Record Sales
| Grade | Mint | Service | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| MS64BN | San Francisco (S) | PCGS | $1,700,000 (2010) |
| MS63BN | Denver (D) | NGC | $1,150,000 (2018) |
| AU55BN | Philadelphia (P) | ANACS | $840,000 (2021) |
(BN = Brown coloration. Prices reflect PCGS/NGC-certified coins only.)
🧪 Authentication: Step-by-Step
- Magnet Test – must NOT stick.
- Precise Weight – 3.11g ±0.05g.
- XRF Analysis – confirms ~95% copper.
- Microscopic Inspection – check for tool marks around the date.
- Grading Submission – PCGS or NGC certification is essential.
🚫 Fake Red Flags:
- Wrong weight
- Slight magnetism (plated steel)
- Casting seams or air bubbles
🧭 Where to Search for One
- Unsearched 1940s coin rolls
- Old estate collections of wheat pennies
- European holdings (used as post-WWII currency)
Last Major Discovery:
A 1943-S bronze cent was found in a Massachusetts attic in 2017 and later sold for $1.1 million.
🛡️ What To Do If You Think You’ve Found One
✅ Handle with cotton gloves
✅ Never clean the coin (even water lowers value)
✅ Take timestamped photos
✅ Store in a secure, non-PVC holder or bank vault
📈 Investment Potential
| Year | Value |
|---|---|
| 1958 | $40,000 |
| 2010 | $1,700,000 |
| 2030 (projected) | $2.5M+ |
Why the value rises:
🔥 Ultra-low population
🏛️ Museum & collector demand
🕰️ Wartime historical significance
🏦 Where to Sell
Top Auction Houses:
- Heritage Auctions – record-setters for rare coins
- Stack’s Bowers – premier numismatic auctions
- Legend Rare Coin Auctions – discreet private treaty sales
💡 Pro Tip: Request PCGS TrueView™ imaging for maximum exposure to global buyers.
Leave a Reply