Everybody Should Know This: Not All Valuable Wheat Pennies Need Errors—Key Dates Matter Most!
When it comes to collecting Lincoln Wheat Pennies, many beginners assume that only coins with striking errors or rare flaws hold significant value. But here’s the truth: some wheat pennies are valuable simply because of their year and mint mark. These are called “key dates”—low-mintage coins that are highly sought after by collectors, even in average condition.
In this guide, I’ll break down the top 10 most valuable regular-issue wheat pennies (no errors required!) so you can spot hidden treasures in your pocket change or inherited collections. Pay close attention—you might already own one of these!
The Top 10 Most Valuable Wheat Pennies (Key Dates)
#10: 1909 VDB Penny
- Avg. Value: $30–$40
- Why It’s Rare: The 1909 VDB (designed by Victor David Brenner) was the first-ever Lincoln cent. While millions were minted, the initials “VDB” were controversially removed mid-year, making early strikes more desirable.
#9: 1913-S
- Avg. Value: $30–$45
- Why It’s Rare: The San Francisco Mint (S) produced far fewer pennies than Philadelphia in 1913. Surviving examples in good condition are scarce.
#8: 1914-S
- Avg. Value: $40–$50
- Why It’s Rare: Low mintage (just 4.1 million) and heavy circulation mean few survive today without wear.
#7: 1912-S
- Avg. Value: $40–$50
- Why It’s Rare: Another San Francisco rarity, with only 4.4 million minted. Look for strong details on Lincoln’s coat.
#6: 1922-D (Denver Mint)
- Avg. Value: $50–$70
- Why It’s Rare: The Denver Mint barely struck pennies in 1922 due to die shortages. Many are weakly struck, but even poor examples fetch a premium.
The Top 5 – Big Money Makers!
#5: 1924-D
- Avg. Value: $60–$75
- Why It’s Rare: Denver’s 1924 output was modest (2.5 million), and surviving coins often show wear.
#4: 1931-S
- Avg. Value: $70–$80
- Why It’s Rare: The Great Depression slashed penny production. Only 866,000 were made in San Francisco—one of the lowest mintages ever!
#3: 1909-S
- Avg. Value: ~$100
- Why It’s Rare: The first-year S-mint penny (no VDB). Just 1.8 million were struck, and most were spent, not saved.
#2: 1914-D
- Avg. Value: $200–$300
- Why It’s Rare: A legendary key date with only 1.1 million minted. Even heavily worn copies sell for $100+.
#1: 1909-S VDB
- Avg. Value: $900–$1,000+
- Why It’s Rare: The holy grail of wheat pennies! The combo of first-year issue + S-mint + VDB initials makes this the most coveted of all. High-grade examples can sell for $5,000+.
Pro Tip:
- Check your coins carefully! A single 1909-S VDB in a jar of old pennies could pay your rent.
- Mint marks matter: Look for “D” (Denver) or “S” (San Francisco) below the date. No mint mark = Philadelphia (common in most years).
Did you find any of these in your collection? Let me know in the comments—and don’t forget to like, follow, and share so more collectors can cash in on these hidden gems!
Leave a Reply